Waiting for Home Prices and Mortgage Rates to Drop? Here’s Why That May Be a Huge Mistake in Today’s Housing Market

by Adam Miller

Let’s talk about one of the most common things we hear from buyers right now:

“We’re just going to wait a little longer — until mortgage rates go down and home prices drop.”

Sound familiar? It’s practically the national anthem of the cautious home shopper in 2025.

But here’s the hard truth: waiting for both to happen at the same time could be a massive mistake. In fact, the last time that did happen was during the worst real estate crash of our lifetime — and it came with foreclosures, short sales, construction freezes, and 50% equity losses.

If you’re holding out for that mythical “perfect moment,” you might miss the best one.

The Myth of the “Perfect Time to Buy a Home”

It feels reasonable, right?
Wait for home prices to drop. Wait for mortgage rates to drop. Lock in the deal of a lifetime.

Here’s the problem: Those two things almost never happen at the same time. Historically:

When interest rates fall, demand rises, and home prices increase
When prices fall, it’s usually tied to economic uncertainty, and lending gets tighter

In other words, low rates and low prices only happen when the market is crashing, and confidence is gone.

Remember 2007–2009? Prices and Rates Fell… but Nobody Was Buying

Let’s go back to the Great Recession — the one time when both prices and rates dropped together. Did that create a flood of smart homebuyers?

Not even close.

In markets like Florida, Arizona, Nevada, and California, home values fell 30–50%. But fear was so high, and lending was so tight, that nobody was buying. Builders abandoned neighborhoods. Short sales and foreclosures flooded the market. And even though mortgage rates dropped to record lows, the system was so frozen that buyers couldn’t or wouldn’t act.

That was not a buyer’s market. That was a financial disaster.

So if you’re waiting for history to repeat itself, ask yourself this: Is that really the kind of market you want to buy into?

What’s Really Happening in Lakewood Ranch and Manatee County in 2025?

Fast forward to today, and the picture looks very different — but still serious.

Here’s what we’re seeing in Lakewood Ranch and the broader Manatee County housing market:

Home prices are dropping, especially on overpriced listings
Mortgage rates are hovering around 6.8%, and likely staying there through 2025
Inventory is rising — there’s more supply, but not more demand
Homes are sitting longer — median time to contract is now 46 days
Sellers are starting to panic, especially as builders crank up the incentives

Let’s take a look at some real numbers:

Closed sales are down 8.6%
Cash sales dropped 13.1%
The average sale price dropped 9.1%
The total dollar volume of sales is down nearly 17%
Median time to sell: 95 days
Active listings are up 17.3%
Months of inventory? Almost 5 months

That’s not a healthy, fast-moving market. That’s a slow, uncertain one, where buyers have leverage.

The Golden Handcuff: Why Inventory Is Still Low in Some Places

Nationally, one thing is keeping housing inventory lower than it should be: the lock-in effect.

Millions of homeowners are “locked in” to ultra-low mortgage rates under 4%. Selling now would mean trading in a $2,000 mortgage for one that’s closer to $3,200 or more — and many just can’t justify that.

This is called the Golden Handcuff. And while it’s freezing inventory across the country, here in Lakewood Ranch we’re seeing a different story…

In Lakewood Ranch: More Construction, More Inventory, More Opportunity

Right now, over 20 neighborhoods in Lakewood Ranch are under active construction. Builders are sitting on move-in-ready homes — and they’re offering massive incentives to unload them.

We just saw:

A $75,000 price cut from a builder
A 4.25% mortgage rate for the first year
A long-term rate as low as 5.25% (compared to the market average of 6.8%)

These are deals that resale sellers simply can’t compete with. That’s why resale listings are sitting longer, getting price reductions, and in many cases, selling well below asking.

Just yesterday, 538 homes adjusted their price in 24 hours.

That’s a market rejecting pricing in real time.

What Does This Mean for Buyers?

If you're a serious buyer, this moment offers a strategic opportunity:

Less competition = more negotiation power
Sellers are motivated
Builders are desperate
You can negotiate closing costs, rate buy-downs, and extras
List-to-sale ratios are hovering around 95.6%, meaning homes are selling below asking price

And here’s something to think about: If you wait until rates do drop, prices may spike again. Competition will return. Bidding wars could be back. And that deal you were waiting for? It’ll be gone.

Real Example: Waiting May Cost You More

Let’s run the numbers.

If you bought today:

$700,000 home
10% down
6.75% rate
Monthly payment: $4,765

Now let’s say you wait a year, and rates drop to 5.75% — but prices rise 10% to $770,000:

Same 10% down
Monthly payment: $4,769

You waited a year… to pay the same amount.
Except now, there’s more competition, fewer concessions, and you lost a year of living in the home you wanted.

What Should You Do Next?

At the 941 Lifestyle Group, we don’t rely on headlines. We look at real numbers, real market shifts, and actual local data. Whether you’re buying, selling, or just confused about what all this means, you need more than a Zestimate — you need a guide.

We're local. We're full-time. And we call it like it is.

👉 Schedule a no-pressure 15-minute call with us
We’ll help you:

Understand your buying power in this market
Compare resale vs. new construction
Identify builder incentives before they’re public
Map out a smart strategy based on your goals

Smart Timing Isn’t About Waiting — It’s About Acting Before the Crowd

The Florida real estate market isn’t crashing — it’s correcting.
Lakewood Ranch is still desirable, but prices are adjusting, homes are sitting longer, and the opportunity window is now.

Don’t wait for perfect. Wait for smart.
And if you're ready to talk about your options, we’re here.

Schedule a 15-Minute Chat

Beyond Homes - We Match Lifestyles

Sign Up To Receive Our Weekly Newsletter